What to Say When Someone Asks What You Watched
Nobody asking what you watched wants a plot summary. They want to know whether it is worth their Friday. Answer in three sentences: what kind of thing it is, what it did to you, and one specific moment that is still in your head. Add a caveat if there is one, because an honest warning makes the recommendation trustworthy. Save the plot entirely, because the plot is the least interesting true thing about any film and it is the one part they can look up.
Lead with the effect, not the story
"It is about a hitman in Paris who" loses the room. "It is ninety minutes of a man doing almost nothing and I could not look away" keeps it.
The effect is what someone is actually deciding on. Nobody chooses a film because of its plot mechanics.
Give one image
One concrete thing you saw. The dinner table. The last shot through a doorway. The moment the music stops.
One image does more persuading than a paragraph of praise, because it proves you actually watched it and that something stuck.
Say the caveat out loud
It is slow for the first half hour. It is subtitled. It has one scene you will find hard. It is three hours.
A caveat makes the recommendation credible and it protects the friendship. Nothing damages your standing like sending someone into three unwarned hours.
Match it to the person, not to your taste
The question behind the question is usually "should I watch this". Answer for them. If they hate subtitles or fall asleep after eleven, say so and suggest the version of your point that fits their life.
Have a shorter answer ready
Sometimes it is small talk and not an enquiry. Have a one line version: "a really good old crime thing, I will send it to you". Then send it. The sending is the part that matters.
- Three sentences: what kind of thing, what it did to you, one specific moment.
- Never lead with plot. It is the part they can look up and the part nobody decides on.
- Say the caveat. It makes the recommendation trustworthy.
- Answer for their taste and their evening, not for yours.
The whole idea
Watch one movie this week. Talk about it Friday.
We pick one film. You watch it alone, on your own time. Friday at 7:30pm PT you get ten minutes on Zoom with one other person who watched it too. No club, no homework, no small talk.
See this week's pick $5Common questions
- How do I describe a movie without spoiling it?
- Describe the effect and the texture rather than events. Tone, pace, how it made you feel and one image that gives nothing away will sell it better than any plot detail.
- How do I recommend a film to someone with different taste?
- Name the thing in it that fits them specifically, and name the thing that might not. Honest caveats are what make a recommendation land.
- What if I did not like it?
- Say that plainly and say what you did like anyway. Mixed recommendations are the most useful ones and the most believable.